When Godzilla Minus One (2023; dir. Takashi Yamazaki) dropped, it rejuvenated the most venerated kaiju after he had been brought to a new low by several schlocky American Godzilla stories like Godzilla vs. Kong. Minus One did this through its unique styling, bringing the story back to post-WWII Japan, and, most importantly, by putting forth a heartfelt story revolving around several makeshift families that make up its emotional core.
Godzilla Minus One delivers in the human moments, exploring themes of guilt, sacrifice, redemption, and collective resolve in ways that echo but also diverge from the original Godzilla (1954).
Theory Must Drive Their Strategy
The film revives the terror of Godzilla by portraying the monster as an unstoppable force of nature, one that does not have any apparent motivations or underlying intentionality.
Godzilla, in this film, is more than just a physical threat—it is a symbol of the unknown. Its existence challenges human understanding and exposes the limitations of knowledge. This portrayal aligns with previous interpretations of Godzilla as a metaphor for nuclear devastation, but Godzilla Minus One expands this metaphor to include humanity’s broader struggle with uncertainty and the limits of control.
The film’s setting in post-war Japan amplifies this theme. Just as the nation is grappling with the uncertainties of rebuilding and redefining itself after the war, the characters must confront the terrifying unpredictability of Godzilla. The monster’s presence forces them to accept that some questions may remain unanswered, and that survival depends not on eliminating uncertainty but on navigating it.
One of the most compelling aspects of the film is how it highlights the tension between theory and practice in the face of the unknown—a dynamic that resonates with the philosophy of science.
In Godzilla Minus One, the characters are faced with a terrifying reality—they know almost nothing about Godzilla. The few facts they have—it’s massive, impervious to conventional weapons, able to heal itself nearly instantaneously, and capable of unimaginable destruction—are insufficient to form a comprehensive understanding of how to defeat it. With so little to go on, the volunteer navy and scientists are forced to rely on theory to devise their strategy.
This reliance on theory creates a fascinating tension, particularly among the navy volunteers, who are deeply unsatisfied with what they perceive as speculative explanations. They demand certainty, something tangible they can act on, but the scientists in the film recognize that certainty is not an option.
This narrative dynamic underscores a crucial truth about the philosophy of science—certainty does not drive scientific progress; skepticism does. The volunteers’ frustration with the scientists mirrors a common misconception about science—that it should provide definitive answers. In reality, science is a process of inquiry, one that thrives on doubt and the willingness to question assumptions.
A good theory is not one that claims to provide absolute certainty but one that can be tested and potentially disproven. In Godzilla Minus One, the scientists embody this principle, presenting their theories not as definitive truths but as tools for guiding action under conditions of uncertainty.
Of course, one can understand why the volunteer navy wouldn’t love this philosophical reality. This theory might, after all, demand their lives with little reward other than the next attempt having slightly more information to go on.
This leads to one of the film’s most powerful moments—the volunteer navy’s collective decision to confront Godzilla, even knowing the extreme likelihood of failure. Their shared resolve reflects a profound sense of courage and unity.
Heroism and Collective Redemption
This collective bravery echoes the emotional resonance of the original Godzilla (1954), particularly the iconic scene of schoolchildren singing a prayerful hymn amidst the devastation. While the hymn symbolized collective mourning and hope, Godzilla Minus One emphasizes action over mourning, showing individuals willingly risking their lives to protect their loved ones about to be confronted by a soon-to-be rampaging Godzilla. Both moments capture the spirit of communal resilience, but they express it in fundamentally different ways—one through reflective symbolism, the other through determined sacrifice.
A particularly moving moment comes when Noda-san, a veteran from the war, reflects on Japan’s treatment of its people during World War II. He openly laments how Japan failed to value human lives, sending soldiers into battle as expendable resources in service of an unjust cause. This battle against Godzilla is an opportunity to redeem their legacy—not necessarily through sacrifice but by doing something meaningful, protecting innocent lives, and proving that the nation can rise above its past mistakes. Noda’s words resonate deeply, providing moral clarity for the navy volunteers as they prepare to face near-certain death for a truly just cause.
The volunteer navy implicitly recognizes that heroism must be tied to righteousness—a commitment to fighting for what is just and meaningful. Unlike hollow heroism glorified in propaganda, their actions are rooted in the defense of innocent lives and the hope for a better future. This distinction transforms their bravery into a truly righteous heroism—one defined not by blind loyalty but by moral clarity and meaningful sacrifice.
The Protagonist’s Journey: Guilt, Redemption, and Forgiveness
While the volunteer navy embodies collective courage, Koichi Shikishima’s journey adds a deeply personal dimension to the film’s exploration of redemption. Haunted by the guilt of purposefully surviving a kamikaze mission while his comrades perished, Koichi’s initial actions are driven by self-loathing and despair. His relationship with Noriko and her adopted daughter, Akiko, represents his fragile attempt to rebuild a life worth living.
When Godzilla devastates Tokyo, Koichi’s guilt deepens, now compounded by his failure to protect his loved ones. This sets the stage for his ultimate act of redemption—a willingness to sacrifice himself to stop Godzilla, even at the possibility of orphaning Akiko a second time. His decision reflects a profound shift—he now accepts responsibility for his role in a world ravaged by war and destruction.
However, Koichi’s journey toward redemption is not defined solely by self-sacrifice. A pivotal moment comes when Tachibana, an airplane mechanic fully aware of Koichi’s earlier cowardice, provides an escape option during his final kamikaze mission. This act of compassion reflects the possibility of forgiveness and a rejection of the idea that redemption always requires the ultimate price. Tachibana’s gesture suggests that survival and living meaningfully are themselves acts of courage, offering Koichi a chance at personal reconciliation.
Akiko serves as both a reminder of Koichi’s failures and a symbol of the life he hopes to protect. His decision to confront Godzilla, even at the risk of leaving her orphaned again, underscores the profound tension between his personal guilt and his desire to ensure a better future for her and others.
Conclusion: Godzilla and the Human Condition
Godzilla Minus One is a triumph not only as a thrilling kaiju film but also as a philosophical exploration of humanity’s relationship with uncertainty.
Its emotional core—centered on Koichi’s redemption, Tachibana’s act of forgiveness, Noda-san’s call for meaningful action, and the collective realization of righteous heroism—reminds us that survival is not just about strategy but about the courage to confront our fears and act in the face of uncertainty.
In a world where we are constantly faced with new challenges—scientific, social, and existential—Godzilla Minus One reminds us that certainty is a luxury we rarely have. What matters is not the absence of doubt but the willingness to engage with it thoughtfully, to act with courage despite it, and to learn from the inevitable failures along the way.
In the end, it is this philosophy of skepticism, forgiveness, and righteous action that allows the characters to face Godzilla—and it is what allows us to navigate the uncertainties of our own lives.
The Curated Life Worth Reading 
Leave a comment